Best Canned & Jarred Crushed Tomatoes Under $200 (2026)
We ranked options by ingredient quality, pack size, sourcing (where stated), processing style, and value score within a (price varies) total budget
The Verdict
- Best Overall: Colavita Crushed Tomatoes - 13.76 oz (16 pack) — Best for low-sodium cooking: plain crushed tomatoes with no-salt-added and simple non-GMO ingredients for flexible recipes
- Best Value: Pomi Chopped Tomatoes 13.8oz (12-pack) Italian tomatoes — Best for Italian-style recipes: chopped Italian tomatoes with non-GMO notes that hold texture in rustic sauces
This roundup covers canned and jarred crushed tomatoes suited to health-conscious cooks, focusing on ingredients, jar size, and value. Picks were chosen by comparing ingredient quality, pack size, origin, and overall value score under a (price varies) total threshold
Top Picks
-
1
Best Overall Colavita Crushed Tomatoes - 13.76 oz (16 pack)
Best for low-sodium cooking: plain crushed tomatoes with no-salt-added and simple non-GMO ingredients for flexible recipes
Colavita crushed tomatoes, non-GMO and no salt added, kosher. Great for sauces; customers note delicious taste and easy opening. Mixed views on crush texture
- no salt added
- non-GMO
- kosher
-
2
Muir Glen Organic Crushed Fire Roasted Tomatoes 14.5 oz (12 pack)
Best for smoky flavor: organic fire-roasted crushed tomatoes that add depth to sauces and chilis without extra additives
Fire-roasted crushed tomatoes made with organic tomatoes. Great for sauces, soups, and stews; adds smoky sweetness. Customers praise flavor and organic quality
- organic + non-GMO verified
- fire-roasted flavor
- versatile canned tomato product
-
3
Sclafani Crushed Tomatoes, 28 oz (Pack of 12)
Best for large-batch sauce: 28 oz cans provide a thicker, vine-ripened base ideal for pizza or pasta preparations
Crushed tomatoes made from vine ripened tomatoes, offering a smooth texture for sauces and recipes. Customers mention sweet flavor and versatile use for sauce, pizza, and pasta
- vine ripened tomato base
- crushed tomato texture
- versatile for multiple dishes
-
4
Tomato crushed canned (28 oz) USA grown – pack of 6
Best for USA-grown sourcing: larger 28 oz cans made from U.S. tomatoes, suited to tomato-forward sauces and stews
Crushed canned tomatoes from USA-grown tomatoes, balanced flavor and smooth texture. Noted for high quality and sauce suitability, with user feedback on taste and sauce results
- balanced flavor and smooth texture
- top ratings from professionals
- sauce-friendly versatility
-
5
Best Value Pomi Chopped Tomatoes 13.8oz (12-pack) Italian tomatoes
Best for Italian-style recipes: chopped Italian tomatoes with non-GMO notes that hold texture in rustic sauces
Chopped tomatoes made from 100% fresh Italian tomatoes with no additives or preservatives. Ideal canned tomatoes alternative with clean ingredients. Customer notes flavor and quality, though some mention higher value for money
- 100% fresh Italian tomatoes
- no additives or preservatives
- gluten-free and non-GMO
-
6
Bianco DiNapoli Organic Crushed Tomatoes in Puree
Best organic puree option: crushed tomatoes in puree form for a smoother, organic base in soups and sauces
Organic crushed tomatoes in puree, ideal for sauces, soups, and stews. Customers note flavor and thick, fresh taste; great for pizza sauce
- organic, vine-ripened tomatoes
- thick texture for robust sauces
- multi-use for recipes
-
7
Bianco DiNapoli Organic Crushed Tomatoes 28 oz (6 pack)
Best for pantry variety: organic 28 oz packs that offer a standard crushed texture for pasta and general cooking
Organic crushed tomatoes for sauces and recipes. High-quality tomatoes with a pleasant sweetness, suitable for wood-fired Napoletana pizzas. Customers note value considerations
- organic crushed tomatoes
- high-quality flavor
- versatile for sauces