Best Paint Mediums & Additives for Card Making (2026)
We prioritized paper compatibility, stencil performance, finish options, ease of use for card makers, and overall value
The Verdict
- Best Overall: The Crafter's Workshop Stencil Butter - Formal Acrylic Paint Set — Best for metallic texture: provides thick, stencil-friendly body and a reflective finish ideal for raised card details
- Best Value: The Crafter's Workshop Stencil Butter - Holiday Acrylic Paint Set — Best for seasonal projects: holiday-focused metallic shades and stencil-ready consistency for festive card accents
This roundup covers paint mediums and additives suited for card making, highlighting products that add texture, metallic sheen, and stencil-friendly body to paper crafts. Picks were chosen for compatibility with paper cardstock, ease of use with stencils, and overall value for crafting and mixed-media card projects
Top Picks
-
1
Best Overall The Crafter's Workshop Stencil Butter - Formal Acrylic Paint Set
Best for metallic texture: provides thick, stencil-friendly body and a reflective finish ideal for raised card details
Acrylic paint set with metallic texture paste for art on various surfaces. Noted for smooth consistency and nice sheen, suitable for stenciling and craft projects
- multisurface compatibility
- smooth texture with shine
- easy-to-use stenciling paint
-
2
Best Value The Crafter's Workshop Stencil Butter - Holiday Acrylic Paint Set
Best for seasonal projects: holiday-focused metallic shades and stencil-ready consistency for festive card accents
A boutique metallic texture paste set for art on canvas, paper, and journals. Noted for beautiful color, smooth consistency, and ease of use for stenciling
- multi-surface compatibility
- texture paste for metallic finish
- creative for cards and journals
-
3
The Crafter's Workshop Stencil Butter Caribbean Sea Set
Best for mixed-media colorways: vivid Caribbean-inspired tones with a paste-like body suited to layered card techniques
Acrylic paint set with metallic texture paste for art on various surfaces. Noted for smooth consistency and nice sheen. Customers mention vibrant colors and ease of use
- suitable for multiple surfaces
- vibrant color quality
- ease of use