Best Toasters for Bagel Toasting (2026)
We selected models that best balance bagel-specific features (bagel mode, slot width), build quality, and price value among 2-slice stainless-steel toasters
The Verdict
- Best Overall: 2-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster with Extra Wide Slots — Best for thicker bagels: extra-wide slots and stainless-steel build for an even, no-squash toast
This roundup compares toasters that handle bagels and other split breads, highlighting slot width, bagel settings, and ease of cleaning. Picks were chosen by assessing fit for bagel toasting, useful features like bagel/defrost modes, and overall value across similar 2-slice stainless steel models
Top Picks
-
1
Best Overall 2-Slice Stainless Steel Toaster with Extra Wide Slots
Best for thicker bagels: extra-wide slots and stainless-steel build for an even, no-squash toast
2-slice retro toaster with 6 browning settings, bagel/defrost/cancel functions and extra wide 1.5 inch slots for thick bread. Customer insight notes its retro design and versatile settings
- six browning levels
- extra wide 1.5 inch slots
- bagel/defrost/cancel functions
-
2
Toaster 2 Slice Stainless Steel with 6 Shade Settings
Best for control: six shade settings plus bagel and defrost modes to fine-tune browning
Stainless steel 2-slice toaster with bagel, defrost, and cancel functions. Hygienic build and even heating technology. Customers note retro look and easy controls, with mixed toast results
- extra-wide slots
- 6 bread shade settings
- removable crumb tray
-
3
Retro stainless steel 2-slice toaster
Best for style-conscious kitchens: retro stainless finish with a bagel function that toasts evenly
The Keenstone retro 2-slice toaster offers 6 browning settings, bagel/defrost/cancel functions, and a wide slot with a removable crumb tray. Customers note vintage look and easy use, with mixed durability and toast quality reports
- 6 browning levels
- bagel/defrost/cancel functions
- extra wide slots
-
4
2-Slice stainless steel toaster with 6 shade settings
Best straightforward performer: six shade settings and a dedicated bagel function for reliable results
The Keenstone 2-slice toaster offers 6 browning settings, bagel function, defrost, and extra-wide slots with a removable crumb tray. Customers note its retro look and ease of use, though some report uneven toasting and concerns about durability
- 6 browning levels
- extra-wide slots
- removable crumb tray