Butter Dishes
A selection of ceramic, stoneware, and stainless butter dishes and keepers designed for countertop storage and serving, with options from budget to premium. The 41 indexed items average a 4.60 rating and include brands like Le Creuset and Butter Bell. Prices range roughly $33 to $259 (average about (price varies))
Top Products
Butter Bell crock for spreadable butter
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with cafe matte glaze
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with matte aqua glaze
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock - cafe matte, steel gray
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock – antique French butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock - original Provencal butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock by L Tremain – antique emerald ceramic butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock - original butter dish
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock set: two ceramic butter dishes
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
Butter Bell crock: original butter dish with cafe matte glaze
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell Crock - Bronze Matte Finish
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
Butter Bell ceramic butter crock with dragon steel finish
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
KIVY Marble Butter Dish with Glass Lid
KIVY
Budget
Chantal Covered Butter Dish Set, White
Chantal
Budget
Butter Bell cow-pattern butter dish crock
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with honey bees pattern
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with raised floral design
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Butter Dish, Oyster
Le Creuset
Budget
Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Butter Dish
Le Creuset
Budget
Radicaln Marble Butter Keeper
Radicaln
Mid-Range
Butter Bell crock with lid, ceramic butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Pfaltzgraff Callie Corn Dishes, 4-pack, blue
Pfaltzgraff
Budget
Le Creuset stoneware butter dish, white
Le Creuset
Budget
Fiesta XL Covered Butter Dish, turquoise ceramic
Fiesta
Mid-RangeRoundups
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose the right size and capacity for a butter dish?
Choose a size based on the typical package of butter you use (e.g., standard 4 oz/113 g stick or larger blocks) and whether you want room for spreads; check internal dimensions and whether the dish holds a single stick, two sticks, or a butter tub
What materials are common for butter dishes and how do they compare?
Common materials include ceramic, stoneware, stainless steel, and food-grade plastic; ceramic and stoneware retain cool temperatures and resist staining, stainless steel is durable and modern-looking, and plastic is lightweight but may absorb odors and scratch more easily
Are there butter dishes designed to keep butter spreadable without refrigeration?
Yes—water-seal butter crocks (also called butter bells) use an inverted cup and water reservoir to create an airtight seal that keeps butter at a spreadable consistency at room temperature for short periods; follow manufacturer care instructions and replace the water regularly
What features should I look for if I want a butter dish that's easy to clean?
Look for dishwasher-safe materials, smooth non-porous glazing or stainless surfaces, removable lids, and minimal crevices where butter can collect; verify the care instructions to confirm oven or dishwasher compatibility if needed
Do decorative or high-end butter dishes affect food safety or functionality?
Decorative and high-end dishes can be fully functional provided they are made from food-safe, lead-free glazes or materials and include practical features like a well-fitting lid; check product specifications for food-safety certifications and cleaning recommendations
Can I use a butter dish for other purposes?
Yes—butter dishes can hold other spreads, soft cheeses, small snacks, or be used as soap dishes; ensure the material is appropriate for the intended use and that you clean between different food types to avoid flavor transfer