Butter Dishes
A selection of ceramic, stoneware, and stainless butter dishes and keepers designed for countertop storage and serving, with options from budget to premium. The 41 indexed items average a 4.60 rating and include brands like Le Creuset and Butter Bell. Prices range roughly $33 to $259 (average about (price varies))
Top Products
Butter Bell crock for spreadable butter
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with matte aqua glaze
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock - cafe matte, steel gray
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with cafe matte glaze
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock – antique French butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock - original Provencal butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock by L Tremain – antique emerald ceramic butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock - original butter dish
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock set: two ceramic butter dishes
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
Butter Bell crock: original butter dish with cafe matte glaze
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell Crock - Bronze Matte Finish
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
Butter Bell ceramic butter crock with dragon steel finish
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
KIVY Marble Butter Dish with Glass Lid
KIVY
Budget
Chantal Covered Butter Dish Set, White
Chantal
Budget
Butter Bell cow-pattern butter dish crock
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with honey bees pattern
Butter Bell
Budget
Butter Bell crock with raised floral design
Butter Bell
Mid-Range
Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Butter Dish
Le Creuset
Budget
Le Creuset Stoneware Heritage Butter Dish, Oyster
Le Creuset
Budget
Radicaln Marble Butter Keeper
Radicaln
Mid-Range
Butter Bell crock with lid, ceramic butter keeper
Butter Bell
Budget
Pfaltzgraff Callie Corn Dishes, 4-pack, blue
Pfaltzgraff
Budget
Le Creuset stoneware butter dish, white
Le Creuset
Budget
Fiesta XL Covered Butter Dish, turquoise ceramic
Fiesta
Mid-RangeRoundups
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose the right size and capacity for a butter dish?
Choose a size based on the typical package of butter you use (e.g., standard 4 oz/113 g stick or larger blocks) and whether you want room for spreads; check internal dimensions and whether the dish holds a single stick, two sticks, or a butter tub
What materials are common for butter dishes and how do they compare?
Common materials include ceramic, stoneware, stainless steel, and food-grade plastic; ceramic and stoneware retain cool temperatures and resist staining, stainless steel is durable and modern-looking, and plastic is lightweight but may absorb odors and scratch more easily
Are there butter dishes designed to keep butter spreadable without refrigeration?
Yes—water-seal butter crocks (also called butter bells) use an inverted cup and water reservoir to create an airtight seal that keeps butter at a spreadable consistency at room temperature for short periods; follow manufacturer care instructions and replace the water regularly
What features should I look for if I want a butter dish that's easy to clean?
Look for dishwasher-safe materials, smooth non-porous glazing or stainless surfaces, removable lids, and minimal crevices where butter can collect; verify the care instructions to confirm oven or dishwasher compatibility if needed
Do decorative or high-end butter dishes affect food safety or functionality?
Decorative and high-end dishes can be fully functional provided they are made from food-safe, lead-free glazes or materials and include practical features like a well-fitting lid; check product specifications for food-safety certifications and cleaning recommendations
Can I use a butter dish for other purposes?
Yes—butter dishes can hold other spreads, soft cheeses, small snacks, or be used as soap dishes; ensure the material is appropriate for the intended use and that you clean between different food types to avoid flavor transfer