The Iliad and the Odyssey Boxed Set vs The Iliad: Homer’s Greek Epic with Selected Writings
Overall winner: The Iliad and the Odyssey Boxed Set
Key Differences
Choose the Homer, Peter Green boxed set (0520306651) if you want an attractively presented, sturdily bound boxed translation with far more customer reviews and a slightly more affordable listed price tier. Choose the Homer, Samuel Butler edition (1528770277) if you prefer a compact single-volume focus on The Iliad that includes selected writings for broader context and a slightly different editorial framing
The Iliad and the Odyssey Boxed Set
A boxed set of ancient poetry featuring an accessible translation and historical introductions. Customers note its aesthetic presentation, sturdy binding, and readability, plus helpful footnotes
Pros
- Aesthetically pleasing presentation
- Sturdy binding
- Readable translation
Cons
- Translation quality noted, but no negatives cited
- No features listed (N/A)
The Iliad: Homer’s Greek Epic with Selected Writings
A collection featuring Homer’s epic alongside selected writings. It offers classic poetry with accessible language and concise insights. Customer note highlights appreciation for the enduring epic style
Pros
- classic Greek epic framing
- includes selected writings for broader context
- compact, readable presentation
Cons
- features show N/A
- mixed insights in customer data
- no additional notes on format details
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Homer, Peter Green |
| Durability | Homer, Peter Green |
| Versatility | Homer, Samuel Butler |
| User Reviews | Homer, Peter Green |