The Real Book Volume II - Second Edition (C Instrument) Jazz Standards vs The Jazz Piano Book
Overall winner: The Real Book Volume II - Second Edition (C Instrument) Jazz Standards
Key Differences
Product A (Hal Leonard) is a songbook with an extensive collection of 400 jazz standards and is presented in an easy-to-read, handwritten-looking font with strong chord annotations, making it ideal for pianists and guitarists who want repertoire. Product B (Mark Levine) is an instructional jazz piano book focused on theory and technique from basics to advanced concepts, better suited for players seeking in-depth instruction rather than a large standards collection
The Real Book Volume II - Second Edition (C Instrument) Jazz Standards
C instrument edition of a classic jazz standards collection with melodies, chords, and progressions. Praised for easy-to-read format and useful chord annotations; mixed views on lyrics inclusion
Pros
- easy-to-read format
- handwritten-looking font
- comprehensive jazz standards
- valued for chord annotations
Cons
- lyrics inclusion is debated
- mixed value for money opinions
The Jazz Piano Book
A comprehensive guide for jazz piano students, from basics to advanced concepts, with valuable theory insights. Customers note its clear learning material and information content, while some find it challenging to read at times
Pros
- comprehensive jazz piano coverage
- insightful theory content
- guiding resource for aspiring players
- includes standard tunes in examples
Cons
- some find it complicated
- some readers find it difficult to read
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Hal Leonard Corp |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Hal Leonard Corp |
| User Reviews | Hal Leonard Corp |