The Real Book Volume II - Second Edition (C Instrument) Jazz Standards vs Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
Overall winner: Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
Key Differences
Bill Evans Omnibook (A) offers 40 accurately transcribed Evans pieces aimed at learning and deepening jazz knowledge, while The Real Book Vol II (B) contains a far larger set of 400 jazz standards with easy-to-read, handwritten-looking charts and strong chord annotations. Choose A if you want focused, detailed transcriptions of Bill Evans' repertoire and slightly more favorable user ratings; choose B if you want a broad, versatile reference of standards for piano and guitar
The Real Book Volume II - Second Edition (C Instrument) Jazz Standards
C instrument edition of a classic jazz standards collection with melodies, chords, and progressions. Praised for easy-to-read format and useful chord annotations; mixed views on lyrics inclusion
Pros
- easy-to-read format
- handwritten-looking font
- comprehensive jazz standards
- valued for chord annotations
Cons
- lyrics inclusion is debated
- mixed value for money opinions
Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
A piano songbook of 40 transcribed jazz classics with authentic solos and notation. Ideal for intermediate/advanced players seeking learning material and accurate transcriptions. Customer feedback highlights quality transcriptions and learning value
Pros
- accurate transcriptions
- authentic solos and notation
- learning material for jazz knowledge
Cons
- not suitable for beginners
- pacing may vary
- song lengths vary
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Bill Evans |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Hal Leonard Corp |
| User Reviews | Bill Evans |