The Eb Real Book, Sixth Edition vs Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
Overall winner: The Eb Real Book, Sixth Edition
Key Differences
The Eb Real Book (0634060759) offers a much larger collection (250 songs) and is noted as easy to read and gig-friendly, while the Bill Evans Omnibook (1540039536) contains 40 piano transcriptions focused on Bill Evans with highly rated, accurate transcriptions for learning. Pick the Real Book if you want broad repertoire and gig utility; pick the Bill Evans Omnibook if you want focused, high-quality piano transcriptions and deeper study of Evans' work
The Eb Real Book, Sixth Edition
A music collection of 250 jazz standards for musicians of all levels. Easy-to-read format supports on-gig reference and impromptu jam sessions. Customers praise its comprehensive content and sturdiness
Pros
- comprehensive collection of 250 songs
- easy to read
- sturdy physical design
- suitable for musicians of all levels
Cons
- no feature details provided
Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
A piano songbook of 40 transcribed jazz classics with authentic solos and notation. Ideal for intermediate/advanced players seeking learning material and accurate transcriptions. Customer feedback highlights quality transcriptions and learning value
Pros
- accurate transcriptions
- authentic solos and notation
- learning material for jazz knowledge
Cons
- not suitable for beginners
- pacing may vary
- song lengths vary
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Bill Evans |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Various |
| User Reviews | Bill Evans |