Complete Works of Aristotle, Vol. 1 vs Plato: Complete Works
Overall winner: Plato: Complete Works
Key Differences
Pick Plato (0872203492) if you want a comprehensive, complete-works edition with readable translation and helpful notes (high rating and many reviews). Pick Aristotle (069101650X) if you want an accessible English translation of Aristotle at a lower listed price tier and better value, but note it’s labeled Vol. 1 / not a complete works and has mixed reports on physical condition
Complete Works of Aristotle, Vol. 1
A collected edition of Aristotle's works translated for English readers, offering a foundation in Western philosophy. One reviewer notes its value despite not being a complete compilation
Pros
- philosophy-rich selection
- valued translation for readability
- notable for broad cultural impact
- perceived value for money
Cons
- not a complete works collection
- mixed physical condition reports
Plato: Complete Works
Accessible translation of Plato's works with helpful notes and content. Readers find the translation readable and thought-provoking with comprehensive content and thoughtful notes
Pros
- readable translation
- helpful notes and footnotes
- comprehensive content
- attractive red hardcover
Cons
- thin pages noted by customers
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Aristotle, Jonathan Barnes |
| Durability | Aristotle, Jonathan Barnes |
| Versatility | Plato, John M. Cooper, D. S. Hutchinson |
| User Reviews | Plato, John M. Cooper, D. S. Hutchinson |