Christian Prayer: The Liturgy of the Hours vs Calling on God: Inclusive Christian Prayers for Three Years of Sundays
Overall winner: Christian Prayer: The Liturgy of the Hours
Key Differences
Product A (International Commission on English in the Liturgy) is a traditional breviary with full Morning Prayer texts and scripture, highly rated by many reviewers, making it better for daily liturgical use and durability. Product B (Peter Bankson, Deborah Sokolove) offers inclusive, three-year Sunday prayers in a devotional format with reflective language and a lower listed price tier, making it better for inclusive Sunday worship and shorter devotional use
Christian Prayer: The Liturgy of the Hours
Official daily prayer collection for Roman Catholic practice. Easy for laypeople to follow with full Morning Prayer texts and breviary content, plus guides for the year
Pros
- easy-to-follow for laypeople
- includes full Morning Prayer texts
- breviary content with scripture
- comes with St Joseph's Guide and yearly guide
Cons
- no features listed for this edition
Calling on God: Inclusive Christian Prayers for Three Years of Sundays
Inclusive Christian prayers collection for Sundays across three years. Benefits readers with structured contemplative prayers and devotional practice. Customer notes reflect appreciation for inclusive approach
Pros
- inclusive prayers across three years
- devotional structure for Sundays
- careful, reflective language
Cons
- no features listed
- no customer insights on negatives
- no sample content provided
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Peter Bankson, Deborah Sokolove |
| Durability | International Commission on English in the Liturgy |
| Versatility | International Commission on English in the Liturgy |
| User Reviews | International Commission on English in the Liturgy |