The Jazz Piano Book vs Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
Overall winner: Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
Key Differences
Bill Evans Omnibook (A) is a collection of 40 transcriptions focused on learning repertoire and is noted for accurate transcriptions and jazz-specific practice; it also sits at a more affordable listed price. Mark Levine's The Jazz Piano Book (B) is a broad instructional text covering basics through advanced theory, making it more versatile for learning concepts and technique despite some readers finding it dense
The Jazz Piano Book
A comprehensive guide for jazz piano students, from basics to advanced concepts, with valuable theory insights. Customers note its clear learning material and information content, while some find it challenging to read at times
Pros
- comprehensive jazz piano coverage
- insightful theory content
- guiding resource for aspiring players
- includes standard tunes in examples
Cons
- some find it complicated
- some readers find it difficult to read
Bill Evans Omnibook for Piano: 40 Transcribed Jazz Classics
A piano songbook of 40 transcribed jazz classics with authentic solos and notation. Ideal for intermediate/advanced players seeking learning material and accurate transcriptions. Customer feedback highlights quality transcriptions and learning value
Pros
- accurate transcriptions
- authentic solos and notation
- learning material for jazz knowledge
Cons
- not suitable for beginners
- pacing may vary
- song lengths vary
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Bill Evans |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Mark Levine |
| User Reviews | Bill Evans |