The Dissertation Journey: planning, writing, and defending your dissertation vs Writing and Doing Action Research
Overall winner: The Dissertation Journey: planning, writing, and defending your dissertation
Key Differences
Carol M. Roberts' book (A) targets doctoral students with structured, section-by-section dissertation guidance and practical tips and has a much larger review sample; Jean McNiff's book (B) focuses on action-research and teacher development with authoritative authorship but far fewer customer reviews. Choose A if you need a hands-on dissertation roadmap and broader user feedback; choose B if your primary need is action-research methodology from a recognized practitioner
The Dissertation Journey: planning, writing, and defending your dissertation
A practical guide for planning, writing, and defending a dissertation. Clear sections, practical tips, and encouragement for doctoral students. A customer notes it breaks down the dissertation process and is easy to read
Pros
- clear information by section
- practical tips
- encouraging tone
- easy-to-read format
Cons
- features: N/A
Writing and Doing Action Research
Guide to action research by Jean McNiff, outlining practical approaches and reflective practice. Insight from user feedback highlights clarity in methodology
Pros
- clear action-research framework
- practical guidance for researchers
- accessible writing style
- reliable author background
Cons
- no listed features
- customer insights labeled None
- limited review data available
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Carol M. Roberts |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Carol M. Roberts |
| User Reviews | Carol M. Roberts |