Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 1: The Lands Between vs Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 2: Shards of the Shattering
Overall winner: Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 2: Shards of the Shattering
Key Differences
Volume 2 (3869931191) focuses on build guides, required stats, maps and images, making it better for players wanting detailed builds and visual aids. Volume 1 (3869931140) emphasizes NPC quest guides and a detailed atlas of The Lands Between but has reported physical damage on some copies, so pick Vol.1 for quest and world detail and Vol.2 for build-focused content and cleaner reception
Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 1: The Lands Between
Strategy guide for Elden Ring detailing NPC quest guides and a detailed atlas. Praised for its design and value, with mixed feedback on physical condition
Pros
- comprehensive NPC quest guides
- detailed atlas of The Lands Between
- gorgeous design
- value for money
Cons
- physical condition issues (damaged edges, dented corners)
Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 2: Shards of the Shattering
Official strategy guide for Elden Ring with detailed information, full build guides, and art-rich visuals. Customers note accurate stats and area strategies, plus impressive maps
Pros
- detailed information
- full build guides with required stats
- high-quality pictures and maps
- armor details and weapon stats
Cons
- no features listed
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Tie |
| Durability | Future Press |
| Versatility | Future Press |
| User Reviews | Future Press |