Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 1: The Lands Between vs Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 3: Shadow of the Erdtree
Overall winner: Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 3: Shadow of the Erdtree
Key Differences
Vol. 1 (3869931140) targets comprehensive NPC quest coverage and a detailed atlas of The Lands Between, making it more versatile for story and exploration help; Vol. 3 (3869931299) focuses on enemy information and detailed maps tied to Shadow of the Erdtree and has slightly higher average rating with fewer reviews but both report potential damaged copies. Choose Vol. 1 if you want broad quest and atlas material; choose Vol. 3 if you prioritize enemy data, map detail, and art quality
Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 1: The Lands Between
Strategy guide for Elden Ring detailing NPC quest guides and a detailed atlas. Praised for its design and value, with mixed feedback on physical condition
Pros
- comprehensive NPC quest guides
- detailed atlas of The Lands Between
- gorgeous design
- value for money
Cons
- physical condition issues (damaged edges, dented corners)
Elden Ring Official Strategy Guide, Vol. 3: Shadow of the Erdtree
A comprehensive strategy guide with enemies, maps, and artwork for Elden Ring. Customers praise its detailed information and fold-out map, while noting beautiful design and gift value
Pros
- rich information on enemies and Lands Between
- detailed maps and fold-out map included
- visually appealing design and artwork
- gift-worthy presentation
Cons
- some damaged copies reported
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Future Press |
| Durability | Future Press |
| Versatility | Future Press |
| User Reviews | Future Press |