HP C5718A DAT DDS-4 Data Cartridge 20 GB native/40 GB compressed vs Sony Mini DV Tape 60min Data Cartridge (10 packs)
Overall winner: Sony Mini DV Tape 60min Data Cartridge (10 packs)
Key Differences
Sony A is a pack of Mini DV tapes praised for tape quality, durable construction and perceived good value, while HP B is a DAT (DDS-4) cartridge with explicit 20 GB native / 40 GB compressed capacity and wider device compatibility but reported fit issues with some Designjet models. Choose Sony if you need reliable Mini DV/DATA tape media and lower-priced bulk packs; choose HP if you need a DAT/DDS-4 format with clear capacity specs for compatible backup devices
HP C5718A DAT DDS-4 Data Cartridge 20 GB native/40 GB compressed
Data cartridge for backup and archival use. 20 GB native / 40 GB compressed capacity with 492.13' tape length. Customers note value for money and compatibility varies across devices
Pros
- good value for money
- works in various printers
- clear capacity specifications
Cons
- fit issues with some Designjet models
- mixed compatibility feedback
- no explicit printer compatibility list
Sony Mini DV Tape 60min Data Cartridge (10 packs)
Mini DV tape set for data storage with 60-minute length. Customers note good tape quality and stable performance in Sony camcorders, with durable construction and good value
Pros
- Tape quality
- Durable construction
- Good value
- Stable video results
Cons
- Some reports of recording time as low as 5 minutes
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Sony |
| Durability | Sony |
| Versatility | HP |
| User Reviews | Sony |