Hoya R72 58mm Infrared Lens Filter vs Cokin Square Filter Infrared Kit (P) Series Holder + Infrared 720 89B
Overall winner: Hoya R72 58mm Infrared Lens Filter
Key Differences
Hoya R72 is a screw-on 58mm infrared filter with a higher rating and many more reviews, making it a straightforward, lens-specific choice for users with 58mm threads and those prioritizing proven user satisfaction. The Cokin kit includes a P-series holder plus an 720nm IR filter, offering compatibility with multiple lens sizes and holder-based workflows—better for photographers who want holder flexibility and landscape techniques
Hoya R72 58mm Infrared Lens Filter
IR pass filter enabling infrared light for creative effects; compatible with mirrorless systems. Users note excellent quality and effective infrared results, with mixed feedback on visibility and ease of use
Pros
- Enhances infrared photography
- Produces unique contrast in images
- Compatible with 58mm lenses
- Good value for infrared photography
Cons
- Sky darkening can be very intense
- Autofocus may not work with filter
- Some users find it difficult to screw on/off
Cokin Square Filter Infrared Kit (P) Series Holder + Infrared 720 89B
Infrared creative kit with a P-Series holder for digital and film photography, enabling surreal landscape results. Includes holder and infrared filter for unique tones
Pros
- Includes P-Series filter holder
- Works with digital and film photography
- Enables surreal landscape photos
- Includes infrared filter
Cons
- No customer data indicates specific drawbacks
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Cokin |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Hoya |
| User Reviews | Hoya |