Hoya R72 58mm Infrared Lens Filter vs X2 IR Infrared Filter for Infrared Photography, Weather-Sealed Frame
Overall winner: Hoya R72 58mm Infrared Lens Filter
Key Differences
Hoya's R72 (58mm) is widely reviewed and noted for strong infrared effect and broad compatibility with 58mm lenses, making it more versatile for users with that thread size. Breakthrough's X2 (52mm) emphasizes build features — weather-sealed frame, ultra-slim double-threaded design, and reduced vignetting — so pick Breakthrough if you need a weather-sealed, slim 52mm filter; pick Hoya if you want a well-reviewed 58mm IR filter with a proven infrared look
Hoya R72 58mm Infrared Lens Filter
IR pass filter enabling infrared light for creative effects; compatible with mirrorless systems. Users note excellent quality and effective infrared results, with mixed feedback on visibility and ease of use
Pros
- Enhances infrared photography
- Produces unique contrast in images
- Compatible with 58mm lenses
- Good value for infrared photography
Cons
- Sky darkening can be very intense
- Autofocus may not work with filter
- Some users find it difficult to screw on/off
X2 IR Infrared Filter for Infrared Photography, Weather-Sealed Frame
Infrared filter with weather-sealed frame and nano coatings for enhanced IR photography. Improves light transmission while reducing vignetting on wide angles. Customer notes indicate clear imaging quality
Pros
- weather-sealed frame design
- eliminates vignetting on wide-angle
- ultra-slim, double threaded
- made with high-purity glass from Japan
Cons
- limited customer sentiment data
- no explicit compatibility details beyond 52mm
- no mention of color cast controls
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Tie |
| Durability | Breakthrough Photography |
| Versatility | Hoya |
| User Reviews | Hoya |