Master Lock outdoor key lock box 5400EC, resettable 4-digit combo vs Kidde AccessPoint Slimline Key Safe with Push Button Combination
Overall winner: Master Lock outdoor key lock box 5400EC, resettable 4-digit combo
Key Differences
Master Lock 5400EC (A) offers larger capacity—holds up to five keys—and a resettable four-digit combination, plus an indoor/outdoor metal body, making it better for multi-key or outdoor use. Kidde KeySafe Original Slimline (B) is a more compact, durable-feeling two-key unit with push-button combination setup and requires mounting hardware, so pick B if you need a slim wall-mounted option for one or two keys
Master Lock outdoor key lock box 5400EC, resettable 4-digit combo
Outdoor key lock box with large capacity for up to five keys and resettable four-digit combination. Durable metal body with vinyl-coated shackle for scratch prevention; suitable for indoor and outdoor use. Customers note reliability and ease of use, though durability is mixed and some report lock jamming
Pros
- large capacity holds up to five keys
- resettable four-digit combination
- durable metal body with vinyl-coated shackle
- suitable for indoor and outdoor use
Cons
- mixed durability feedback
- some reports of lock jamming within a month
Kidde AccessPoint Slimline Key Safe with Push Button Combination
Combination key safe for permanent wall-mount storage of up to 2 keys. Keyless entry via customizable push-button combo with over 1,000 options. Includes mounting hardware for easy setup
Pros
- Permanent wall-mount design
- Push-button combination with many options
- Includes mounting hardware
- Suitable for indoor or outdoor use
Cons
- Limited to 2 keys
- Single user access method (no digital app)
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Master Lock |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Master Lock |
| User Reviews | Master Lock |