D'Addario XL Nickel Bass Strings EXL165TP 4-string set (45-105) long scale vs DR Black Beauties Bass 5 Strings 45-130
Overall winner: D'Addario XL Nickel Bass Strings EXL165TP 4-string set (45-105) long scale
Key Differences
D'Addario EXL165TP (A) is a long-scale 4-string nickel-wound set with a lower listed price tier, very high user ratings (4.80 from 10,650 reviews) and notes of durable construction and bright tone. DR Black Beauties (B) is a 5-string set offering increased volume and clearer articulation with a K3 coating, but has mixed longevity reports and lower rating (4.70 from 4,384 reviews). Choose A if you want a highly rated, durable 4-string long-scale nickel set; choose B if you need a 5-string with more output and articulation
D'Addario XL Nickel Bass Strings EXL165TP 4-string set (45-105) long scale
Nickel-wrapped bass strings for bright, tight tone and durable playability. Praised for quality, brightness, and longevity across performances
Pros
- bright tone
- durable construction
- smooth feel
- good value for money
Cons
- brightness may vary by instrument
- long-scale set only specified
- some users report brightness consistency over shows can vary
DR Black Beauties Bass 5 Strings 45-130
DR's K3-coated bass strings deliver clear tone with more volume and articulation. Customers praise sound quality and smooth feel, with some noting longer life and improved look on basses
Pros
- increased volume
- clearer articulation
- smooth under fingers
- appealing appearance
Cons
- mixed longevity reports
- some failures at tuning peg ends
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | D'Addario |
| Durability | D'Addario |
| Versatility | DR Strings |
| User Reviews | D'Addario |