Armor All Car Protectant Refill 1 gal vs Black Plastic Restorer for Cars - restores faded trim
Overall winner: Armor All Car Protectant Refill 1 gal
Key Differences
Armor All (A) is a general interior protectant with a higher rating (4.70 from 4,132 reviews) and is marketed to clean and protect multiple interior surfaces with UV protection and a non-greasy finish; That Stuff (B) focuses specifically on restoring black plastic trim, has a lower rating (4.20 from 2,874 reviews), and reports more issues with mixed color results and streaking. Choose Armor All if you want a versatile interior protectant and stronger user satisfaction; choose That Stuff if your primary need is restoring faded black exterior trim and quick drying
Armor All Car Protectant Refill 1 gal
Armor All Original Formula car interior protectant that cleans and protects vinyl, plastic, and rubber surfaces with UV protection. It adds shine and revives surfaces while leaving no residue, backed by user praise for value and effectiveness
Pros
- cleans and protects interior surfaces
- UV protection to reduce fading
- non-greasy, no residue
- large 1 gallon refill bottle
Cons
- look may be mixed among customers
Black Plastic Restorer for Cars - restores faded trim
Installs a quick-restoring formula for black plastic trim on vehicles. Restores appearance and dries quickly, with feedback noting easy application and longevity. One customer insight highlights effectiveness on autos and motorcycles
Pros
- restores faded black plastic trim
- easy to apply
- dries quickly
- long-lasting appearance
Cons
- mixed color results
- streaking or smudging reported
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Armor All |
| Durability | Armor All |
| Versatility | Armor All |
| User Reviews | Armor All |