MARSHALLTOWN Cast Magnesium Hand Float, 16" x 3-1/8" vs Marshalltown Resin Hand Float 20 x 3-1/2 in with DuraSoft handle
Overall winner: Marshalltown Resin Hand Float 20 x 3-1/2 in with DuraSoft handle
Key Differences
Marshalltown Cast Magnesium Hand Float (A) is a 16in magnesium float noted for a smooth finish and multiple handle options, and it sits at a more affordable price tier. The Marshalltown Resin Hand Float (B) is a larger 20 x 3-1/2in resin float that evaporates bleed water and is described as more durable than wood, with mixed feedback on build and handle quality
MARSHALLTOWN Cast Magnesium Hand Float, 16" x 3-1/8"
Magnesium hand float for smoothing and finishing air-entrained concrete. Balanced 16" blade with knuckle clearance and choice of handles for comfort. Customers note its smooth finish and lightweight design; durability is mixed
Pros
- balanced blade for smooth finishing
- choice of comfortable handles
- lightweight design
- cast magnesium construction for durability
Cons
- mixed durability feedback
- some reports of fragile finish
Marshalltown Resin Hand Float 20 x 3-1/2 in with DuraSoft handle
Resin hand float with laminated canvas resin blade for smooth finish and bleed water evaporation. Effective for working color hardeners into concrete; durable and USA-made. Customer notes quality and straightness, with durable shape
Pros
- smooth finish from laminated canvas resin
- bleed water evaporation
- easy to work color hardeners into concrete
- longer lasting than wood float
Cons
- mixed feedback on build and handle quality
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | MARSHALLTOWN |
| Durability | Marshalltown |
| Versatility | MARSHALLTOWN |
| User Reviews | Tie |