Werther's Original Chewy Caramel Candy, 5 oz Bags (Pack of 12) vs Walkers' Nonsuch Liquorice Toffees with Condensed Milk & Black Treacle
Overall winner: Walkers' Nonsuch Liquorice Toffees with Condensed Milk & Black Treacle
Key Differences
Walkers' Nonsuch (A) offers a traditional British liquorice-toffee profile and emphasizes premium ingredients like real butter, while Werther's Original (B) focuses on creamy, smooth chewy caramel and comes individually wrapped for sharing. A has a lower listed price tier and higher average rating with far fewer reviews; B has far more reviews, indicating broader customer exposure but reports of mixed melting/wrapper issues and value perceptions
Werther's Original Chewy Caramel Candy, 5 oz Bags (Pack of 12)
Chewy caramel candies with real butter and fresh cream for a smooth flavor. Customers note creamy smoothness and soft vanilla center as a positive insight
Pros
- Chewy caramel texture
- Creamy smoothness with vanilla center
- Individually wrapped for sharing
- Made with real butter and fresh cream
Cons
- Mixed opinions on value for money
- Mixed melt rate and wrapper performance
- Some wish bags were larger
Walkers' Nonsuch Liquorice Toffees with Condensed Milk & Black Treacle
Traditional British toffees with liquorice, condensed milk, and black treacle. Rich liquorice flavor and soft, chewy texture. Customers appreciate the texture and licorice taste, with some noting freshness concerns
Pros
- traditional British toffee
- rich liquorice flavor
- soft, chewy texture
- premium ingredients
Cons
- some reports of stale texture
- mixed freshness experiences
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Walkers' Nonsuch |
| Durability | Werther's Original |
| Versatility | Walkers' Nonsuch |
| User Reviews | Walkers' Nonsuch |