Replacement pan for 54" Midwest dog crate (SL54DD), black vs 22.75 x 16.63 in metal crate pan, 1 in high
Key Differences
MidWest (A) is positioned as the direct replacement pan for a specific 54-inch SL54DD crate and has a higher review count with a matching rating, while Pinnacle (B) is a galvanized metal pan noted for durable metal construction and broader fit compatibility but requires careful size checking. Choose A if you need a guaranteed fit for the 54" MidWest SL54DD and prefer the larger volume of user feedback; choose B if you want a chew-resistant metal pan that fits many crate models and prioritizes durability
Replacement pan for 54" Midwest dog crate (SL54DD), black
Leak-proof polypropylene replacement pan for 54-inch Midwest double door crates. Slide-out design eases cleaning and maintenance; versatile as a multi-purpose tray around the home. Customer note: fits well and offers good value, with mixed remarks on durability
Pros
- Leak-proof replacement pan
- Slide-out for easy cleaning
- Durable injection-molded design
- Multi-purpose tray around the house
Cons
- Mixed feedback on sturdiness/durability
- Some concerns about size perceptions
- Occasional reports of damage on arrival
22.75 x 16.63 in metal crate pan, 1 in high
Sturdy galvanized metal crate pan designed to fit most single or double door crates. Easy to clean and durable, with reported chew resistance and versatile as a multi-purpose tray. A user notes it’s easy to wipe clean and works for crate and bird cages
Pros
- durable galvanized material
- easily cleaned
- chew resistance for some pets
- fits various crate sizes
Cons
- confirm correct size to avoid returns
- mixed value on cost for some buyers
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | MidWest Homes for Pets |
| Durability | Pinnacle Systems |
| Versatility | Pinnacle Systems |
| User Reviews | MidWest Homes for Pets |