Elkay 25" Drop-In Single Bowl Stainless Steel Sink vs Elkay Dayton 17" Drop-In Single Basin Kitchen Sink
Overall winner: Elkay 25" Drop-In Single Bowl Stainless Steel Sink
Key Differences
Pick A (Elkay D12522) if you want a larger 25" drop-in single basin and a more affordable listed price; pick B (Elkay D11719) if you prefer the 17" model that emphasizes high-quality stainless steel and similar build. Both share the same rating and similar mixed opinions about mounting hardware, but A offers a larger basin for big pots while B highlights value for money in a smaller footprint
Elkay 25" Drop-In Single Bowl Stainless Steel Sink
Drop-in stainless steel sink with a 25" x 22" basin and 3 faucet holes. ADA compliant when properly installed. Customers praise quality, value, and easy installation
Pros
- stainless steel 300-series build
- drop-in installation for easy mounting
- uninterrupted single bowl workspace
- ample basin size for pots and pans
Cons
- mixed opinions on mounting hardware
Elkay Dayton 17" Drop-In Single Basin Kitchen Sink
17" drop-in stainless sink with 1 faucet hole and 300-series steel. Quiet sound-deadening features reduce noise during use. Customers note good quality and value, with easy installation and fitting size for large pots
Pros
- Drop-in installation for easy setup
- Quiet sound-deadening pad reduces noise
- 300-series stainless steel for everyday use
- Good quality and value noted by customers
Cons
- Mixed feelings about mounting hardware
- ADA compliance depends on proper installation
- Installation may require under-sink work
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Elkay |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Elkay |
| User Reviews | Tie |