Rubbermaid Slim Jim trash can swing lid, blue (23 gal) vs Rubbermaid Slim Jim Trash Can Swing Lid, Green
Overall winner: Rubbermaid Slim Jim trash can swing lid, blue (23 gal)
Key Differences
Product A (green) is marketed as an interchangeable, color-coded top that fits multiple Slim Jim containers, making it more versatile for sorting systems. Product B (blue) emphasizes a rust‑proof durable resin build and a 23‑gal capacity; it focuses on hands‑free swing-down access but shares similar mixed durability feedback and flap issues
Rubbermaid Slim Jim trash can swing lid, blue (23 gal)
Swing lid trash can lid for Slim Jim containers; hands-free access with a durable, rust-proof resin. Some customers note the flap closure can be heavy-duty yet may fall apart with normal use
Pros
- hands-free lid access
- swing-down flap design
- rust-proof durable resin
- compatible with Slim Jim 23 gallon cans
Cons
- flap closure may fall apart with normal use
- mixed durability/quality reports
Rubbermaid Slim Jim Trash Can Swing Lid, Green
Swing lid for Slim Jim 23-gallon containers; space-saving top with color-coded interchanges for waste separation. Customers note good fit against walls but mixed feedback on flap closure durability
Pros
- space-saving swing lid
- interchangeable, color-coded tops
- fits multiple Slim Jim containers
- desk-side or behind-bar suitability
Cons
- flap closure may not stay closed
- mixed durability and quality feedback
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Rubbermaid Commercial Products |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Rubbermaid Commercial Products |
| User Reviews | Tie |