Greenies Vet-Recommended Natural Dental Dog Treats Teenie Size vs Tartar Shield Soft Rawhide Chews for Large Dogs
Overall winner: Greenies Vet-Recommended Natural Dental Dog Treats Teenie Size
Key Differences
Greenies Teenie (B001G96UK8) has a lower listed price tier, much higher user rating (4.80 from 67,692 reviews) and is marketed as natural, vet-recommended dental treats for breath-freshening. Tartar Shield Soft Rawhide (B0BVSX36LQ) targets large dogs with a soft texture and VOHC approval but has a lower rating (4.30 from 871 reviews) and reported durability issues and occasional vomiting
Greenies Vet-Recommended Natural Dental Dog Treats Teenie Size
Natural dental treats for dogs supporting plaque, tartar, gums, and breath. Veterinarian-recommended, with natural ingredients and added vitamins. Customers note good value and strong appeal for picky dogs
Pros
- Supports plaque and tartar reduction
- Veterinarian-recommended dental treats
- Natural ingredients with vitamins and nutrients
- Appeals to picky dogs
Cons
- Contains no artificial flavors or preservatives (per customer note)
- Teenie size may not suit larger dogs
Tartar Shield Soft Rawhide Chews for Large Dogs
Soft rawhide chews for dogs with dental benefits and fresh breath. Clinically reduces plaque and tartar; helps support healthy teeth and gums. Users report noticeable teeth cleanliness and palatability, though some note variable chew duration
Pros
- soft rawhide surface for easy chewing
- clinically proven to reduce plaque and tartar
- fresh breath support
- vet VOHC approved
Cons
- durability varies; some chews last ~60 seconds
- some dogs may vomit or have digestive issues
- softer texture may be softer than expected
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Greenies |
| Durability | Tartar Shield |
| Versatility | Greenies |
| User Reviews | Greenies |