Downtown Pet Supply Poop Bags with Dispenser, 2200 Count vs Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder & 900 Bags
Overall winner: Downtown Pet Supply Poop Bags with Dispenser, 2200 Count
Key Differences
Earth Rated (A) bundles a durable dispenser and 900-count bags with strong durability feedback and is offered at a lower listed price tier; Downtown Pet Supply (B) provides a much larger 2200-count supply and emphasizes leak-proof design but has mixed reports about thickness and occasional bottom tearing. Choose A if you want a sturdy dispenser and a more affordable packaged option; choose B if you prioritize a very large supply and color variety despite some variability in bag thickness
Downtown Pet Supply Poop Bags with Dispenser, 2200 Count
Large leak-proof poop bags with a dispenser for leash use. Perforated rolls for easy tearing; includes 2200 bags and a bone-shaped holder. Customers note good quality and color variety, with mixed feedback on thickness
Pros
- includes a reusable dispenser
- perforated for easy tearing
- color variety
Cons
- thickness varies by customer
- some reports of bottom tearing
Earth Rated Dog Poop Bag Holder & 900 Bags
Durable poop bag dispenser with leakproof, unscented bags. Easy load and grab on walks, with a secure click-and-lock closure. Customers note durability and value, plus the 900-count option is praised
Pros
- durable bag dispenser
- secure click-and-lock closure
- unscented bags
- easy to load and dispense
Cons
- no scent option mentioned for bags
- no multi-pack alternatives listed
- no compatibility details with leash types
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Earth Rated |
| Durability | Earth Rated |
| Versatility | Downtown Pet Supply |
| User Reviews | Tie |