Marshalltown Hawk Masonry Trowel with DuraSoft Handle vs Marshalltown 14-inch aluminum hawk with dura-soft handle

Overall winner: Marshalltown Hawk Masonry Trowel with DuraSoft Handle

Key Differences

Choose A (Marshalltown 14in Aluminum Hawk) if you want a lighter aluminum blade and a lower listed price tier with easy-to-clean blade and DuraSoft handle. Choose B (Marshalltown 12in Composite Hawk) if you want a composite blade that "won't warp" and includes a callus preventer for added durability and comfort despite being in a higher price tier

Marshalltown Hawk Masonry Trowel with DuraSoft Handle

Marshalltown Hawk Masonry Trowel with DuraSoft Handle

Marshalltown The Premier Line • ★ 4.1/5 • Mid-Range

Masonry hawk with 12-inch composite blade, includes callus preventer and DuraSoft handle. Lightweight, comfortable grip and solid build for sheetrock mud and loading cornerbeads

Pros

  • DuraSoft handle design
  • callus preventer included
  • corrosion-resistant composite blade
  • won't warp

Cons

  • no explicit size variants mentioned
Check current price on Amazon →
Marshalltown 14-inch aluminum hawk with dura-soft handle

Marshalltown 14-inch aluminum hawk with dura-soft handle

Marshalltown The Premier Line • ★ 4.1/5 • Mid-Range

A 14-inch aluminum hawk with a DuraSoft handle and callus preventer for comfortable use. Made in the USA; suitable for masonry and drywall tasks. Customers note lightweight design and easy cleaning

Pros

  • lightweight design
  • comfortable grip with padded handle
  • easy to clean
  • durable aluminum blade

Cons

  • none stated explicitly
Check current price on Amazon →

Head-to-Head

CriteriaWinner
Price Marshalltown The Premier Line
Durability Marshalltown The Premier Line
Versatility Marshalltown The Premier Line
User Reviews Tie