Winsor & Newton Collection Drawing Ink Set (8) vs Dr. Ph. Martin's Bombay India Ink Set 1, 12 bottles
Overall winner: Dr. Ph. Martin's Bombay India Ink Set 1, 12 bottles
Key Differences
Winsor & Newton (A) is a more affordable ink set with bright pigments and fast-drying performance but reports mixed flow and some surface staining. Dr. Ph. Martin's (B) is a higher-tier set with vibrant, lightfast and waterproof inks when dry, includes droppers and a mixing palette, though bottles may leak if laid down
Winsor & Newton Collection Drawing Ink Set (8)
A collection of soluble-dye drawing inks in a shellac solution for strong color and quick-drying results. Includes Canary Yellow, Orange, and Carmine; suitable for dip pen drawing and color layering. Customers report vibrant pigments and good value, with mixed flow feedback
Pros
- vibrant color quality
- quick-drying ink
- includes multiple colors
- good value for money
Cons
- mixed feedback on ink flow
- potential for surface staining
Dr. Ph. Martin's Bombay India Ink Set 1, 12 bottles
Set of 12 1.0 oz glass India inks with droppers and mixing palette. Vibrant, lightfast and waterproof when dry. Customers note quick drying and lasting color with some bottle leakage reports
Pros
- 12 vibrant India inks
- glass bottles with droppers
- mixing palette included
- lightfast and waterproof when dry
Cons
- bottle leakage reports when laid down
- mixed reviews on bottle durability
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Winsor & Newton |
| Durability | Dr. Ph. Martin's |
| Versatility | Dr. Ph. Martin's |
| User Reviews | Winsor & Newton |