Winsor & Newton Collection Drawing Ink Set (8) vs Dr. Ph. Martin's Bombay India Ink Set (12 bottles, 1 oz each)
Overall winner: Dr. Ph. Martin's Bombay India Ink Set (12 bottles, 1 oz each)
Key Differences
Winsor & Newton (A) offers a more affordable option with bright pigments and fast-drying inks but has mixed flow and some surface-staining risk. Dr. Ph. Martin's (B) is a higher-tier set with vibrant color variety, smooth application and inks that are lightfast and waterproof when dry, though some users report smearing
Winsor & Newton Collection Drawing Ink Set (8)
A collection of soluble-dye drawing inks in a shellac solution for strong color and quick-drying results. Includes Canary Yellow, Orange, and Carmine; suitable for dip pen drawing and color layering. Customers report vibrant pigments and good value, with mixed flow feedback
Pros
- vibrant color quality
- quick-drying ink
- includes multiple colors
- good value for money
Cons
- mixed feedback on ink flow
- potential for surface staining
Dr. Ph. Martin's Bombay India Ink Set (12 bottles, 1 oz each)
A set of 12 1.0 oz glass ink bottles with droppers and a mixing palette for vibrant India inks. Ideal for calligraphy, watercolor, and mixed-media; noted for color variety and smooth application
Pros
- vibrant color variety
- easy to layer
- smooth application
- includes droppers and mixing palette
Cons
- smearing reported by some users
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Winsor & Newton |
| Durability | Dr. Ph. Martin's |
| Versatility | Dr. Ph. Martin's |
| User Reviews | Tie |