Sloan A-1001-A Diaphragm Rebuild Kit for Regal Flushometers vs Kohler GP1059291 Toilet Tank Canister Valve Seal 6-pk
Overall winner: Sloan A-1001-A Diaphragm Rebuild Kit for Regal Flushometers
Key Differences
Sloan A-1001-A is a complete diaphragm rebuild kit specifically for 4.5 GPF Regal flushometers and includes all necessary parts for installation, while Kohler GP1059291 is a 6-pack of genuine Kohler canister valve seals for Class 5/6 toilets that emphasizes chemical resistance. Pick the Sloan kit if you need a full rebuild for a Regal flushometer and want a lower listed price; pick the Kohler seals if you need OEM replacement seals for Kohler Class 5/6 canisters and greater chemical resistance
Sloan A-1001-A Diaphragm Rebuild Kit for Regal Flushometers
Diaphragm rebuild kit for Sloan Regal flushometers with 4.5 GPF. Includes parts for a successful install and optimized water usage. Customers note easy installation and good value, with some reports of leakage concerns
Pros
- comprehensive rebuild kit
- helps limit water consumption
- easy to install
- good value for money
Cons
- reports of leakage by some users
Kohler GP1059291 Toilet Tank Canister Valve Seal 6-pk
Kohler genuine part GP1059291 seal set for toilet tank canisters. Yellow seal resists wear from chemicals and use. customers note easy installation
Pros
- genuine Kohler part
- yellow seal resists leaks
- chemicals and wear resistant
- easy to install (customer insight)
Cons
- specific to Kohler Class 5 and Class 6 canister toilets
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Sloan |
| Durability | Kohler |
| Versatility | Sloan |
| User Reviews | Sloan |