Marshalltown 14-inch aluminum hawk with dura-soft handle vs Kerdi square-notching trowel 1/8 x 1/8 (1-pack) TRL-KER
Overall winner: Marshalltown 14-inch aluminum hawk with dura-soft handle
Key Differences
Pick the Marshalltown hawk (A) if you want a lightweight aluminum masonry hawk with a comfortable DuraSoft handle and higher review volume; pick the Schluter trowel (B) if you need a precise 1/8" x 1/8" square-notch tool for tile mortar application, but note some reports of rust and mixed handle feedback
Marshalltown 14-inch aluminum hawk with dura-soft handle
A 14-inch aluminum hawk with a DuraSoft handle and callus preventer for comfortable use. Made in the USA; suitable for masonry and drywall tasks. Customers note lightweight design and easy cleaning
Pros
- lightweight design
- comfortable grip with padded handle
- easy to clean
- durable aluminum blade
Cons
- none stated explicitly
Kerdi square-notching trowel 1/8 x 1/8 (1-pack) TRL-KER
Trowel designed for precise 1/8" x 1/8" thin-set mortar coverage and Kerdi membrane installation. Comfort-focused handle and durable design noted by users
Pros
- durable design
- precise 1/8" x 1/8" application
- ergonomic handle
- well-made and comfortable to use
Cons
- some reports of rusting after use
- mixed opinions on handle quality
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Marshalltown The Premier Line |
| Durability | Marshalltown The Premier Line |
| Versatility | Marshalltown The Premier Line |
| User Reviews | Marshalltown The Premier Line |