Smead 89415 Three-Ring Binder Index Divider 5-Tab White vs Avery 5-Tab Insertable Multicolor Binder Dividers (11109)
Overall winner: Avery 5-Tab Insertable Multicolor Binder Dividers (11109)
Smead 89415 Three-Ring Binder Index Divider 5-Tab White
Divide materials inside any 3-ring binder with assorted 1/5-cut tabs for quick category identification. 11 point white stock offers everyday use and durability; customers note sturdy quality and value, with good durability in humidity
Pros
- 3-ring binder compatibility
- assorted 1/5-cut tabs for quick identification
- 11 point white stock for everyday use
- handwrite on tab or apply a self-adhesive label
Cons
- paper weight noted as not heavy weight by some customers
Avery 5-Tab Insertable Multicolor Binder Dividers (11109)
Multicolor 5-tab insertable binder dividers for 3-ring binders with reinforced tabs. Features large visibility tabs and 50% more writing space. Customers value durability and practicality for classroom organization
Pros
- reinforced plastic tabs for durability
- large, easy-to-see tabs
- more writing space on tabs
- suitable for school, home, or office
Cons
- depends on 3-ring binder compatibility
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Avery |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Avery |
| User Reviews | Tie |