Progresso Traditional Chicken Tortilla Gluten Free Soup (18.5 oz x12) vs Campbell's Pub-Style Chicken Pot Pie Soup - 16.3 oz Can
Overall winner: Progresso Traditional Chicken Tortilla Gluten Free Soup (18.5 oz x12)
Key Differences
Progresso (A) is a gluten-free chicken tortilla soup sold in 18.5 oz cans and is described as chunky chicken and vegetables and ready-to-eat in minutes; Campbell's (B) is a 16.3 oz pub-style chicken pot pie soup featuring vegetables and dumplings with reported variability in thickness. Choose Progresso if you need a gluten-free, chunkier tortilla-style canned soup and prefer a lower listed price tier; choose Campbell's if you specifically want a pot-pie–style soup with dumplings and higher protein per serving
Progresso Traditional Chicken Tortilla Gluten Free Soup (18.5 oz x12)
Gluten-free canned soup with chicken, vegetables, and tortilla flavor. Ready to eat in minutes; customers note satisfying texture and chunkiness of chicken and veggies
Pros
- gluten-free ingredients
- contains chicken and vegetables
- ready-to-eat convenience
- textural richness noted by customers
Cons
- some customers report dented cans
- texture may vary by batch
Campbell's Pub-Style Chicken Pot Pie Soup - 16.3 oz Can
Campbell's Chunky Pub-Style Chicken Pot Pie Soup in a 16.3 oz can. Hearty meal with chicken, vegetables, and dumplings; praised for flavor and cooking convenience. Customer notes include chunky chicken and plenty of dumplings
Pros
- chunky chicken pieces
- dumplings and vegetables included
- easy to heat and eat
- protein-rich per can
Cons
- soup thickness varies by review
- some cans arrive dented
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Progresso |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Progresso |
| User Reviews | Progresso |