Progresso Creamy Mushroom Soup, gluten free, 18 oz (12 pack) vs Campbell's Condensed Cream of Mushroom Soup (6 packs of 4 cans)
Overall winner: Campbell's Condensed Cream of Mushroom Soup (6 packs of 4 cans)
Key Differences
Choose Campbell's (A) if you want a well-rated, compact pantry staple with a higher average review score and a lower listed price tier; choose Progresso (B) if you need a larger gluten-free option with no artificial flavors and prefer a bigger can count per unit. Both have reported dented cans, but Campbell's is notably higher rated and marketed as a versatile condensed soup while Progresso emphasizes gluten-free and vegetable ingredients
Progresso Creamy Mushroom Soup, gluten free, 18 oz (12 pack)
Creamy mushroom soup with portabella mushrooms in a thick broth. Gluten-free and ready to eat in minutes. Customer note: some cans may lack noodles and texture varies
Pros
- gluten-free
- creamy texture
- ready-to-eat can
- vegetarian-friendly
Cons
- some cans lack noodles
- texture and flavor mixed reviews
Campbell's Condensed Cream of Mushroom Soup (6 packs of 4 cans)
Cream of mushroom soup with mushrooms, garlic, and farm-fresh cream. Versatile base for casseroles and sauces; suitable as a pantry staple. One customer notes its use in crock pot meals
Pros
- versatile pantry staple
- smooth flavor from cream
- good base for sauces and casseroles
- pre-packaged in multi-pack
Cons
- dented cans reported by some customers
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Campbell's |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Campbell's |
| User Reviews | Campbell's |