Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz vs Colorations Washable Tempera Paint Set of 6 Colors
Overall winner: Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz
Key Differences
Crayola (A) offers 12 colors in larger bottles and a lower listed price tier, plus a higher average rating (4.80 from 4,085 reviews), making it better for broader projects and heavier use. Colorations (B) is a smaller 6-color set with strong safety and washability claims but fewer colors and fewer reviews (4.70 from 2,221), so it suits users wanting a basic, non-toxic starter set
Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz
Crayola washable tempera paint set with 12 colors in 16-ounce bottles. Great for classroom art projects and everyday crafts; praised for washability and color variety by customers
Pros
- washable from brushes and surfaces
- varied color assortment
- sufficient paint quantity per bottle
- durable for classroom use
Cons
- broken lids reported
Colorations Washable Tempera Paint Set of 6 Colors
Vibrant, non-toxic tempera paints in a six-color set for kids' crafts and projects. Ideal for classroom or home use, delivering washable color for easy cleanup. Customer notes emphasize bright hues and versatile crafting potential
Pros
- non-toxic for safe use
- washable from most surfaces
- vibrant color assortment
- suitable for kids' crafts
Cons
- limited color variety in set of 6
- colors listed include only black, blue, green (potentially others not specified)
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Crayola |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Crayola |
| User Reviews | Crayola |