Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz vs Fantastory 12-color tempera paint set (16.9 oz each) for kids
Overall winner: Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz
Key Differences
Crayola (A) lists slightly smaller bottles but has a higher average rating and more reviews, with pros like washable paints and varied colors though some users reported broken lids. Fantastory (B) offers marginally larger bottles and is also washable and non-toxic, but some users reported thin consistency and mixed pigment/coverage quality
Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz
Crayola washable tempera paint set with 12 colors in 16-ounce bottles. Great for classroom art projects and everyday crafts; praised for washability and color variety by customers
Pros
- washable from brushes and surfaces
- varied color assortment
- sufficient paint quantity per bottle
- durable for classroom use
Cons
- broken lids reported
Fantastory 12-color tempera paint set (16.9 oz each) for kids
12-color washable tempera paint set for kids with 16.9 oz bottles. Non-toxic and ASTM/EN compliant; easy to wash off and child-friendly. Customers note vibrant colors and good value, with mixed feedback on pigment thickness
Pros
- 12 vibrant color bottles
- washable and non-toxic
- large bottle size minimizes reordering
- child-friendly packaging
Cons
- paint thickness reported as thin by some users
- mixed feedback on pigment quality and coverage
- glitter variety described as transparent and gelatinous
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Crayola |
| Durability | Crayola |
| Versatility | Tie |
| User Reviews | Crayola |