Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz vs Colorations SWT16 Simply Washable Tempera Paints, 16 oz, Set of 11
Overall winner: Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz
Key Differences
Crayola (Product A) offers one more color (12 vs 11) and comes from a higher-rated product with more reviews; it also lists washable performance from brushes and surfaces and larger per-bottle quantities. Colorations (Product B) emphasizes vibrant, opaque consistency but notes variable paint thickness and similar cap break reports; choose Crayola for a larger color assortment, higher user rating, and perceived value, or Colorations if you prioritize particularly vibrant, opaque finishes
Crayola Washable Paint Set (12 colors) 16 oz
Crayola washable tempera paint set with 12 colors in 16-ounce bottles. Great for classroom art projects and everyday crafts; praised for washability and color variety by customers
Pros
- washable from brushes and surfaces
- varied color assortment
- sufficient paint quantity per bottle
- durable for classroom use
Cons
- broken lids reported
Colorations SWT16 Simply Washable Tempera Paints, 16 oz, Set of 11
Colorations Simply Washable tempera paints set features vibrant, opaque color suitable for kids' art on non-greasy surfaces. Customers note strong color and easy washability, with some concerns about paint thickness and durability of caps and containers
Pros
- vibrant colors
- washable on kids' art surfaces
- opaque consistency
- value for amount included
Cons
- paint thickness varies by user
- caps may break off
- containers may arrive cracked
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Crayola |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Crayola |
| User Reviews | Crayola |