Simplehuman 40L Slim Kitchen Step Trash Can vs Smudge resistant small rectangular trash can with soft-close pedal
Overall winner: Simplehuman 40L Slim Kitchen Step Trash Can
Key Differences
Choose simplehuman (A) if you want a space-saving slim design with a silent-close lid and a lock to keep pets out and prefer a lower listed price; choose Amazon Basics (B) if you value a stainless-steel build with a removable inner bucket and a lid that can stay open for easier use and cleaning
Simplehuman 40L Slim Kitchen Step Trash Can
Slim 40L/10.6 gal trash can with silent close lid and slide lock. Ideal for narrow spaces; builds well and holds bags securely around the rim. Customers note quiet lid and effective pet deterrence, with occasional lid-stay-open issue
Pros
- silent close lid
- slide lock to keep lid shut
- slim, space-saving design
- lid stays open for longer tasks
Cons
- lid sometimes won't stay open
Smudge resistant small rectangular trash can with soft-close pedal
Smudge-resistant stainless steel trash can with a soft-close lid and removable bucket for easy disposal. Customers note its compact size fits small spaces and easy cleaning, though some find it too small for kitchen use
Pros
- soft-close lid
- removable bucket
- carry handle for easy transport
- stain-resistant stainless steel
Cons
- size may be too small for some uses
- lid closure may vary by unit
- some units reported breakage after months
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | simplehuman |
| Durability | Amazon Basics |
| Versatility | simplehuman |
| User Reviews | simplehuman |