Walker’s Shortbread Scottie Dogs cookies 3.9 oz box (pack of 6) vs Lorna Doone Shortbread Cookies, 12 boxes (36 snack packs)
Overall winner: Lorna Doone Shortbread Cookies, 12 boxes (36 snack packs)
Key Differences
Walker's Scottie Dog packs are marketed as a giftable shortbread with a higher review count and cute shaped presentation, while NABISCO Lorna Doone offers 36 individually wrapped snack packs with slightly higher average rating and more reviewers noting consistent crumble and individual packaging. Choose Walker's if you want a giftable, shaped shortbread presentation; choose Lorna Doone if you prefer individually wrapped snack portions and a marginally higher average rating
Walker’s Shortbread Scottie Dogs cookies 3.9 oz box (pack of 6)
Butter shortbread cookies in Scottie dog shapes with a simple traditional recipe. Crisp, crumbly texture and pure ingredients highlight the buttery flavor. Customer note: cute presentation and good freshness, with some reports of broken cookies
Pros
- buttery shortbread flavor
- cute Scottie dog shapes
- traditional Scottish recipe
- pure ingredient feel
Cons
- some cookies arrive broken
- size and value perceptions vary
Lorna Doone Shortbread Cookies, 12 boxes (36 snack packs)
Shortbread cookies with a rich, buttery flavor and crumbly texture. Individually wrapped packets for snacks and desserts; pairs well with coffee or tea, according to customer feedback
Pros
- crunchy, crumbly shortbread texture
- individually wrapped snack packs
- versatile for snacks and desserts
- classic shortbread flavor
Cons
- some customers say not fresh
- crunchiness varies by batch
- packaging may vary
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Tie |
| Durability | NABISCO |
| Versatility | Walkers |
| User Reviews | NABISCO |