Westbrass 593144-12 tub waste drain kit, oil rubbed bronze vs Trimscape Toe-Touch Tub Overflow Drain, Polished Nickel
Overall winner: Trimscape Toe-Touch Tub Overflow Drain, Polished Nickel
Key Differences
Westbrass (A) is positioned as the more affordable option with positive notes on easy installation and appealing appearance but has mixed quality feedback and reports of paint peeling. Kingston Brass (B) is built from solid brass with a corrosion-resistant finish and clearer fit specifications (fits 1.5" pipe, 2-3/4" drain diameter, 1-7/8" external thread), making it a sturdier choice for longevity
Westbrass 593144-12 tub waste drain kit, oil rubbed bronze
Tub waste drain kit with 1-1/2 in. black tubular assembly and toe-tip plug. Includes two-hole faceplate and screws, with slip joint connections. Customers note easy installation and nice appearance, but mixed quality and sizing concerns
Pros
- easy to install
- appealing appearance
- functional drain plug
Cons
- mixed quality reports
- paint peeling reported
- size may be too short for some soaker tubs
Trimscape Toe-Touch Tub Overflow Drain, Polished Nickel
Toe-touch tub overflow drain in polished nickel, with 1-1/2" threaded drain and corrosion-resistant brass construction. Easy installation and durable design. Customer note highlights solid construction and nice finish
Pros
- solid brass construction
- corrosion-resistant finish
- easy installation
- fits 1.5" pipe (nominal)
Cons
- external thread diameter 1-7/8"
- 11.5 threads per inch
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Westbrass |
| Durability | Kingston Brass |
| Versatility | Westbrass |
| User Reviews | Kingston Brass |