Westbrass 593144-12 tub waste drain kit, oil rubbed bronze vs PVC Freestanding Tub Drain Kit for Freestanding Bathtubs
Overall winner: Westbrass 593144-12 tub waste drain kit, oil rubbed bronze
Key Differences
Westbrass (A) is the more affordable option with a larger review sample and a long-standing tubular bath waste design in an oil-rubbed-bronze/black finish, while MUDGUD (B) is a slightly higher-priced freestanding tub drain kit that emphasizes sturdy brass tubes and an all-in-one PVC-compatible assembly but has some fit concerns for certain 2" pipes
Westbrass 593144-12 tub waste drain kit, oil rubbed bronze
Tub waste drain kit with 1-1/2 in. black tubular assembly and toe-tip plug. Includes two-hole faceplate and screws, with slip joint connections. Customers note easy installation and nice appearance, but mixed quality and sizing concerns
Pros
- easy to install
- appealing appearance
- functional drain plug
Cons
- mixed quality reports
- paint peeling reported
- size may be too short for some soaker tubs
PVC Freestanding Tub Drain Kit for Freestanding Bathtubs
PVC drain kit for freestanding, floor-mounted, and island bathtubs. Stable installation with brass tubes and PVC adapter, reducing backflow and odors. Customers report easy assembly and good value
Pros
- stable installation on wood, cement, tile
- brass tubes for durability
- easy assembly and included pieces
- reduces water backflow and odors
Cons
- 2" pipe fit reported as loose by one reviewer
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Westbrass |
| Durability | MUDGUD |
| Versatility | Westbrass |
| User Reviews | Westbrass |