SmartSign Blank Shipping Tags with pre-attached loops vs Avery Metal Rim Key Tags 6-Pack, 1.25" Diameter
Overall winner: Avery Metal Rim Key Tags 6-Pack, 1.25" Diameter
Key Differences
Avery's metal rim key tags (6-pack) offer reinforced metal rims and writable surfaces on both sides, making them more versatile for labeling small items; they also sit at a more affordable price tier and have a higher average rating. SmartSign's shipping tags are bulk manila cardstock with a reinforced fiber patch and pre-attached cotton loops, better suited for shipping/packaging uses and heavier-duty cardstock needs but have a smaller eyelet diameter and no color variants noted
SmartSign Blank Shipping Tags with pre-attached loops
Blank manila shipping tags with reinforced fiber patch and pre-attached cotton loops. Durable 10-point cardstock for easy writing. Customers note sturdy construction and good value for labeling items
Pros
- reinforced fiber patch for durability
- pre-attached cotton loop strings
- treated writable surface for pencil, pen, or marker
- large 5.25 x 2.625 inch size for info
Cons
- eyelet diameter may limit some tag attachments
- manila color may show dirt over time
- stated 10 point thickness unspecified for all uses
Avery Metal Rim Key Tags 6-Pack, 1.25" Diameter
Metal rim key tags for identification with writable surfaces on both sides. Reinforced for wear and tear; valued for versatility in key labeling and organization. Customers note good value and quality for temporary use
Pros
- reinforced metal rim tags resist tearing
- double-sided writable surfaces
- versatile for key labeling and identification
- easy to attach rings
Cons
- durability mixed vs expected
- some users find them less sturdy over time
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Avery |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Avery |
| User Reviews | Avery |