Gerber Organic Apple Carrot Squash Stage 2 Puree Pouch (12-pack) vs Plum Organics 6+ Months Fruit & Veggie Pouches Variety Pack
Overall winner: Gerber Organic Apple Carrot Squash Stage 2 Puree Pouch (12-pack)
Key Differences
Gerber (A) is a Stage 2 apple-carrot-squash single-flavor 12-pack with a higher average rating and highlights two servings of fruit & vegetable per pouch; Plum Organics (B) is a mixed-flavor variety pack for 6+ months featuring broader flavor options (apple, broccoli, pear, banana, apricot, carrot) but has mixed feedback on expiration dates and vegetable content. Choose Gerber if you prioritize a highly rated single organic blend and consistent serving info; choose Plum Organics if you want a wider range of fruit-and-veg flavors for variety
Gerber Organic Apple Carrot Squash Stage 2 Puree Pouch (12-pack)
Organic stage 2 baby food puree pouch with apple, carrot, squash. Convenient, portable, re-closable; provides fruit and veggie servings per pouch. Customers note easy use and organic ingredients
Pros
- organic ingredients
- re-closable, portable pouch
- two servings of fruit & veggie per pouch
- stage 2 texture for advancing feeding
Cons
- no added sweetener is stated but no explicit allergen caution
- description focuses on 12-pack; individual pouch details not listed
Plum Organics 6+ Months Fruit & Veggie Pouches Variety Pack
Organic baby food pouches for 6 months and older, with natural fruit and veggie purees for on-the-go feeding. Consumers note convenient packaging and balanced flavors, with some concern about expiration dates
Pros
- organic fruit and veggie puree
- on-the-go convenient pouches
- family-friendly flavors (apple, broccoli, pear, banana, apricot, carrot)
- stage 2 suitable for 6+ months
Cons
- mixed reviews on expiration dates
- mixed reactions to vegetable content
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Gerber |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Plum Organics |
| User Reviews | Gerber |