SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box vs DNA Motoring Roof Storage Box 12.7 cu ft
Overall winner: SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box
Key Differences
SportRack (A) offers a larger-capacity, rear-opening ABS cargo box with higher average rating and many reviews, and emphasizes tool-free mounting for convenient access; DNA Motoring (B) is a slightly smaller 12.7 cu ft universal-fit box that advertises quieter operation and sturdy build but has fewer reviews and a lower average rating. Choose SportRack if you prioritize capacity, rear access, and broader user feedback; choose DNA Motoring if you prefer a quieter, reportedly sturdy box and a universal-fit design
SportRack Vista XL Rear Opening Cargo Box
Rear-opening cargo box for vehicles with 18 cu ft capacity.durable UV-resistant ABS and tool-free mounting for easy installation, plus lock for securing contents. Customers note easy installation and sturdy performance
Pros
- large storage capacity
- easy, tool-free mounting
- rear opening for convenient access
- durable UV-resistant material
Cons
- rear opening may require clearance for access
- noisy wind resistance noted by some users
DNA Motoring Roof Storage Box 12.7 cu ft
Universal heavy-duty roof cargo carrier with 12.7 cu ft capacity and 110 lb load rating. Builds with impact-resistant ABS and side-opening design for easy access; some users report fit issues with certain vehicles
Pros
- easy to install
- sturdy build quality
- quiet operation
- large storage capacity
Cons
- fit may vary by vehicle
- some report brittle feel
- lock mechanism issues noted
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | DNA MOTORING |
| Durability | SportRack |
| Versatility | SportRack |
| User Reviews | SportRack |