Brown Mulch Dye, 6,400 sq ft Coverage, Mulch Colorant for Landscaping vs Petra Black Mulch Dye Spray for faded mulch (32 oz, 3600 sq ft)
Overall winner: Petra Black Mulch Dye Spray for faded mulch (32 oz, 3600 sq ft)
Key Differences
COLORBACK (A) is a highly concentrated 1/2-gallon brown dye that covers large areas and is presented as more cost- and time-saving; Petra (B) is a 32 oz black spray formulated for deep black color with long-lasting binding technology but notes possible wash-off and fading after a few months. Choose COLORBACK if you need broader coverage and a concentrated solution for brown mulch; choose Petra if you want a ready-to-mix black spray with specialized binding for deeper black color
Brown Mulch Dye, 6,400 sq ft Coverage, Mulch Colorant for Landscaping
ColorBack Brown Mulch Dye restores faded mulch color with a high-concentration formula for large areas. One reviewer notes it works well for large areas and saves money by extending mulch life
Pros
- restores faded mulch color
- highly concentrated formula
- covers large areas per treatment
- saves time and money
Cons
- may stain unintended surfaces
- sprayer clogging reported by users
Petra Black Mulch Dye Spray for faded mulch (32 oz, 3600 sq ft)
Petra black mulch dye with wetting agents for even application; helps restore color on rubber, pine straw, bark, cedar, and playground mulch. Users note easy mixing and application, with deep color and good coverage
Pros
- Deep black colorant
- Even application with wetting agents
- High coverage per quantity
- Long-lasting binding technology
Cons
- Durability may vary with weather
- Some customers report fading after months
- Washes off with rain for some users
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | COLORBACK |
| Durability | Petra |
| Versatility | COLORBACK |
| User Reviews | Tie |