Doheny’s 1.5 HP above-ground pool pump (115V, 83 GPM) vs Little Giant LG-APCP1700 pool cover pump 1/3 hp
Overall winner: Little Giant LG-APCP1700 pool cover pump 1/3 hp
Key Differences
Choose Little Giant (A) if you want an automatic submersible cover pump with a built-in handle and 1" FNPT discharge (includes garden-hose adapter) and prefer a lower listed price tier. Choose Doheny's (B) if you need a higher-power above-ground pool pump with a stainless-steel motor shaft, reinforced thermoplastic body, and emphasis on efficiency and low noise
Doheny’s 1.5 HP above-ground pool pump (115V, 83 GPM)
Durable Doheny’s pool pump with stainless steel shaft and reinforced thermoplastic body for efficient, low-noise operation. Customers note quiet performance and easy installation, with some variability in lifespan reports
Pros
- stainless steel motor shaft
- reinforced thermoplastic body
- high efficiency and low noise
- 1.5" internal threading and 2.5" external threading
Cons
- no on/off switch
- mixed lifespan reports from customers
Little Giant LG-APCP1700 pool cover pump 1/3 hp
Automatic submersible pool cover pump for removing water from covers and other surfaces. Features a 25-ft cord and easy access for cleaning; users report solid build and effective water removal, with mixed feedback on auto shut-off
Pros
- automatic operation
- built-in handle for portability
- 1" FNPT discharge with garden hose adapter
- 25 ft power cord for easy reach
Cons
- auto shut-off may be inconsistent
- mixed durability over years
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Little Giant |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Little Giant |
| User Reviews | Little Giant |