Thetford 42138 Style 2 Toilet Base vs Camco RV Premium Travel Toilet with Detachable Tank
Key Differences
Camco (A) is a complete portable travel toilet with a detachable holding tank, pump flush and odor-sealing design, while Thetford (B) is a replacement Style II toilet base focused on installation and build quality. Choose Camco if you want a full portable, pump-flush unit and detachable tank; choose Thetford if you need a reliable base unit with quality materials for an existing RV toilet setup
Thetford 42138 Style 2 Toilet Base
The base kit for Thetford Style II toilets, model 42138. Designed to restore bathroom functionality with solid quality and fit. Customers cite easy installation and reliable functionality, though sealing and leakage concerns are noted
Pros
- easy to install
- reliable functionality
- quality materials
- good fit with compatible models
Cons
- mixed feedback on sealing
- leakage reports from some users
Camco RV Premium Travel Toilet with Detachable Tank
Compact RV toilet with a detachable 6-gallon holding tank and pump flush. Easy to empty, seal prevents odors, and durable ABS construction. Customers praise ease of use, cleaning, and odor control
Pros
- Detachable holding tank for easy emptying
- Pump flush action for bowl rinsing
- Odor-sealing tank design
- Durable ABS resin construction
Cons
- Mixed opinions on size and fit
- Some reports of water seepage from fresh water tank
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Camco |
| Durability | Thetford |
| Versatility | Camco |
| User Reviews | Thetford |