Shortbread Fingers Selection Tin vs Lorna Doone Shortbread Cookies, 12 boxes (36 snack packs)
Overall winner: Lorna Doone Shortbread Cookies, 12 boxes (36 snack packs)
Key Differences
Choose NABISCO Lorna Doone (A) if you want individually wrapped snack packs and a higher average rating with many reviewers praising buttery flavor and crumbly texture. Choose the Shortbread Fingers tin (B) if you prefer a handmade selection with four flavors (original, stem ginger, dark chocolate, dark chocolate & orange) in a large tin and individually wrapped packets inside
Shortbread Fingers Selection Tin
Handmade shortbread fingers in a large tin with a fine selection: Original, Stem Ginger, Rich Dark Chocolate, and Dark Chocolate & Orange. Includes four separately wrapped packets; praised for taste and buttery texture with balanced sweetness
Pros
- handmade texture and buttery flavor
- variety of flavors in one tin
- separately wrapped portions for freshness
- tea and coffee pairing versatility
Cons
- mixed freshness experiences on arrival
- some perceive price as high
- cookie quality feedback is not uniformly positive
Lorna Doone Shortbread Cookies, 12 boxes (36 snack packs)
Shortbread cookies with a rich, buttery flavor and crumbly texture. Individually wrapped packets for snacks and desserts; pairs well with coffee or tea, according to customer feedback
Pros
- crunchy, crumbly shortbread texture
- individually wrapped snack packs
- versatile for snacks and desserts
- classic shortbread flavor
Cons
- some customers say not fresh
- crunchiness varies by batch
- packaging may vary
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | NABISCO |
| Durability | Tie |
| Versatility | Shortbread |
| User Reviews | NABISCO |