Purina Nicker Makers Horse Treats 15 lb bag vs UMAID Himalayan Salt Lick on Rope for Livestock 6 lbs (4 Pack)
Overall winner: UMAID Himalayan Salt Lick on Rope for Livestock 6 lbs (4 Pack)
Key Differences
UMAID salt licks (A) are an all-natural Himalayan salt product with an on-a-rope design and 84 trace minerals, suited for livestock needing a mineral supplement; Purina Nicker Makers (B) are flavored horse treats in a 15 lb pack designed for feeding and training, with higher reported liking but some mold reports. Choose A if you want a mineral lick/durable hanging option for livestock; choose B if you want flavored, easy-to-feed treats for training and rewards
Purina Nicker Makers Horse Treats 15 lb bag
Extruded horse treats in fun size and shape, easy to feed and eat. Horses love the taste, with a favorable size for pocket-carrying convenience. Customer feedback notes moldy occurrences among some purchases
Pros
- fun size and shape
- easy to feed and eat
- liked by horses for flavor
- portable size mentioned by customers
Cons
- some reports of moldy treats
- perceived as expensive by some customers
UMAID Himalayan Salt Lick on Rope for Livestock 6 lbs (4 Pack)
Natural Himalayan salt on a durable rope for horses and livestock. Provides 84 trace minerals and longer-lasting salt lick. Customers note easy hanging and good value, with rope durability mixed
Pros
- all natural Himalayan salt
- includes sturdy rope
- longer lasting than pressed licks
- provides 84 trace minerals
Cons
- rope durability mixed among customers
- dissolves quickly in rain
Head-to-Head
| Criteria | Winner |
|---|---|
| Price | Purina |
| Durability | UMAID |
| Versatility | UMAID |
| User Reviews | UMAID |